Craving The Best Lobster Roll in New York? Check Out Our Top Picks!
New York City, the concrete jungle that never sleeps, is not just famous for its iconic skyline and Broadway shows. It’s also a culinary heaven, offering diverse dishes to tantalize your taste buds. One of the city’s hidden seafood gems is its delectable lobster rolls.
Join me on a mouthwatering journey through the 11 best lobster roll in New York. Brace yourself for a burst of flavors and an unforgettable seafood experience!
11 Best Lobster Roll in New York
1. Luke’s Lobster
First on our lobster roll adventure is Luke’s Lobster. Nestled in the city’s heart at 207 E 43rd St, this cozy eatery has satisfied New Yorkers’ seafood cravings for years. The lobster roll is a true classic – succulent chunks of lobster meat, lightly seasoned and served on a buttery, toasted roll. It’s simplicity at its finest, allowing the lobster’s natural sweetness to shine.
See More: Best Things to Do in New York in December
2. Burger & Lobster
If you’re looking for a one-of-a-kind lobster roll experience, head over to Burger & Lobster at 39 W 19th St. They’re known for their inventive approach to the classic dish. Here, you can enjoy a lobster roll with a twist – a juicy lobster patty topped with fresh greens and drizzled with their secret sauce. It’s a burger lover’s dream with a seafood surprise.
3. Red Hook Lobster Pound
To taste the sea with a touch of nostalgia, visit Red Hook Lobster Pound at 16 Extra Pl. This charming spot offers lobster rolls that transport you straight to the shores of Maine. The lobster is fresh and flavorful, and the rolls are perfectly buttered and toasted, giving you a delightful crunch with every bite.
Seam ore’s
If you’re a seafood lover, you will want to see Seamore’s at 161 8th Ave. Their lobster roll is a masterpiece of culinary artistry. Imagine succulent lobster meat dressed in a zesty mayo and served on a brioche bun, topped with fresh herbs and a hint of lemon zest. It’s a symphony of flavors to make your taste buds dance joyfully.
Related Post: Best Corned Beef Sandwich in New York City
5. The Lobster Place
Located within Chelsea Market at 75 9th Ave, The Lobster Place is a seafood lover’s paradise. Their lobster roll is a testament to their commitment to freshness and quality.
The lobster is so tender it practically melts in your mouth. The added touch of celery and herbs provides a refreshing contrast, making it a must-try for lobster enthusiasts.
6. Lobster Joint
If you’re searching for a spot that offers quality and affordability, Lobster Joint at 1073 Manhattan Ave is your go-to. Their lobster roll is generous in portion and rich in flavor.
The lobster is complemented by a light mayo dressing, allowing the sweetness of the seafood to shine through. Plus, the laid-back, beachy vibes of the place add to the overall experience.
7. Ed’s Lobster Bar
At 222 Lafayette St, Ed’s Lobster Bar is an authentic seafood haven. Their lobster roll is the epitome of elegance and taste. The lobster is served on a perfectly toasted roll with shoestring fries. It’s a culinary delight that captures the essence of both classic and modern New York.
8. Cull & Pistol
Nestled in the Chelsea Market at 75 9th Ave, Cull & Pistol offers a lobster roll that’s a work of art. The lobster is poached in butter, ensuring each bite is a heavenly experience. Adding pickled onions and a sprinkle of chives provides a delightful contrast of flavors, making it a must-try for seafood connoisseurs.
9. Pearl Oyster Bar
Located at 18 Cornelia St, Pearl Oyster Bar is a cozy seafood spot perfect for an intimate meal. Their lobster roll is a testament to their dedication to quality. The lobster meat is incredibly fresh, and the roll is buttery perfection. It’s no wonder that Pearl Oyster Bar is often hailed as one of the city’s best seafood joints.
10. Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co.
For those who appreciate sustainability, Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. at 114 Nassau Ave is the place to be. Their lobster roll showcases ethically sourced lobster, ensuring a guilt-free indulgence. The lobster is lightly dressed with lemon aioli, and the registration is a fluffy, pillowy delight. It’s a win-win for your taste buds and the environment.
Read Also: Best Cheesesteak In New York City
11. Grand Central Oyster Bar
Our lobster roll journey concludes at the iconic Grand Central Oyster Bar in Grand Central Terminal. Located at 89 E 42nd St, this timeless establishment has served seafood lovers for over a century. Their lobster roll is a timeless classic – plump lobster meat, fresh lettuce, and a hint of mayo, all nestled in a buttery roll. It’s a taste of history that you will remember.
FAQs
What makes Luke’s Lobster stand out among the other lobster roll spots in NYC?
Luke’s Lobster stands out for its simplicity and dedication to letting the natural sweetness of lobster shine. The succulent lobster chunks, lightly seasoned and served on a buttery, toasted roll, create a classic and delicious experience.
Which lobster roll spot in NYC is perfect for those looking for a unique twist on the classic dish?
Burger & Lobster is the go-to spot for a unique take on the classic lobster roll. They serve a lobster patty topped with fresh greens and a secret sauce, combining the best burgers and seafood in one dish.
Are there any sustainable options for lobster rolls in NYC?
Yes, Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. is known for its commitment to sustainability. They offer lobster rolls made from ethically sourced Lobster, ensuring a guilt-free indulgence in delicious seafood.
Conclusion
In the city that never sleeps, these 11 lobster roll spots are a testament to New York’s culinary diversity. Whether you prefer a classic rendition or an innovative twist, there’s a lobster roll for everyone in the Big Apple. So, embark on this flavorful journey and savor the taste of the sea in the concrete jungle’s heart.
