15 Best Corned Beef Sandwich in New York City: A Delectable Journey
New York City, a melting pot of cultures and cuisines, is renowned for its diverse culinary scene. The corned beef sandwich stands tall as a timeless classic among the city’s gastronomic treasures. Delightful, savory, and satisfying, this sandwich has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike.
In this article, I’ll take you on a mouthwatering journey to explore the 15 best-corned beef sandwiches in New York City, each offering a unique blend of flavors and experiences.
The Allure of the Corned Beef Sandwich:
The corned beef sandwich is a symphony of flavors, combining tender, succulent corned beef with various accompaniments and condiments, all embraced by slices of freshly baked bread. The interplay of textures and tastes creates a delightful experience that’s hard to resist.
Whether you prefer it with mustard, sauerkraut, or a special sauce, a corned beef sandwich in New York City is bound to satisfy your cravings.
Read Also: Best Cheesesteak In New York City
15 Best Corned Beef Sandwich in New York City
1. Katz’s Delicatessen
Katz’s Delicatessen is a New York institution serving corned beef sandwiches for over a century. With its historic charm and bustling atmosphere, stepping into Katz’s feels like stepping back in time. The corned beef sandwich, a towering masterpiece, is packed with layers of succulent, marinated beef that practically melts in your mouth.
The slow-cooked perfection of the meat is complemented by the tangy bite of mustard and the soft embrace of fresh rye bread. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Katz’s Delicatessen offers a meal and a cultural experience.
Address: 205 E Houston St, New York, NY 10002
Why They’re Best:
- A slice of history since 1888.
- Legendary towering corned beef sandwich.
- Perfectly marinated and slow-cooked beef.
- The iconic spot is featured in numerous films.
2. Carnegie Deli
Carnegie Deli is synonymous with hearty portions and bold flavors, and its corned beef sandwich lives up to its reputation. The sandwich is a towering masterpiece, brimming with an impressive mound of tender, succulent corned beef. Each bite is a flavor explosion, with the meat being the show’s star.
The rye bread holds up well against the generous portion, ensuring that every mouthful is a satisfying experience. Carnegie Deli’s corned beef sandwich is a true classic that pays homage to New York’s deli tradition.
Address: 854 7th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Why They’re Best:
- Monumental corned beef sandwich.
- Generous portion that might need a to-go bag.
- A flavorful and impressive pile of meat.
- Known for its celebrity clientele.
3. Mile End Deli
Mile End Deli is a haven for those seeking authentic Jewish deli flavors. Their corned beef sandwich is a celebration of old-world charm and culinary expertise. The corned beef, brined to perfection, boasts a depth of flavor that can only come from slow and meticulous preparation.
The house-baked bread is the ideal canvas for this flavorful creation, ensuring that each bite is a harmonious blend of textures and tastes. With a commitment to locally sourced ingredients, Mile End Deli offers a sandwich and a culinary journey through time.
Related Post: Best Falafel in New York
Address: 97 Hoyt St, Brooklyn, NY 11217
Why They’re Best:
- Old-world charm with Jewish deli tradition.
- Brined and house-baked goodness.
- Transporting you back to simpler times.
- Emphasis on locally sourced ingredients.
4. Harry & Ida’s
Harry & Ida’s is a gem in the East Village, known for its dedication to handcrafted perfection. Their corned beef sandwich is a testament to their commitment to quality. The beef is marinated and cooked with meticulous care, resulting in a depth of flavor that’s simply unmatched.
Every element, from the pickles to the mustard, is thoughtfully prepared in-house, contributing to a symphony of tastes that dance on the palate. Harry & Ida’s offers not just a sandwich but a testament to the artistry of culinary craftsmanship.
Address: 189 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009
Why They’re Best:
- Handcrafted perfection in the East Village.
- Dedication to high-quality, in-house ingredients.
- Meticulous preparation for harmonious flavors.
- Known for their artisanal approach.
Others Post: Ribeye vs. New York Strip
5. Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop
Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop in the Flatiron district is a step back in time, embracing the nostalgia of classic diners. Their corned beef sandwich is a straightforward yet exceptional creation. With an emphasis on authenticity, the sandwich boasts a generous serving of tender corned beef rich in flavor.
The no-frills approach highlights the quality of the meat itself, while the traditional rye bread provides the perfect foundation. Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop captures the essence of comfort food and delivers it with genuine charm.
Address: 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
Why They’re Best:
- Reliving nostalgia in Flatiron.
- No-frills approach with authentic experience.
- It’s a straightforward yet exceptional sandwich.
- Adored by both locals and tourists.
6. The Butcher’s Daughter
The Butcher’s Daughter brings innovation to the corned beef sandwich with a plant-based twist. Their version features “corned” beets that are artfully marinated to mimic the flavors of traditional corned beef. The result is a sandwich that’s as visually appealing as it is flavorful.
Combining house-made ingredients and carefully chosen accompaniments ensures a satisfying experience, even for those who prefer a vegetarian option. The Butcher’s Daughter showcases creativity and sustainability in reimagining a beloved classic.
Address: Multiple Locations
Why They’re Best:
- A veggie twist on the classic.
- Plant-based “corned” beets for a delightful alternative.
- It’s a satisfying sandwich for vegetarians.
- Focus on organic and sustainable ingredients.
7. Pastrami Queen
As the name suggests, Pastrami Queen reigns supreme regarding pastrami and corned beef. Their hand-sliced corned beef is a testament to their commitment to quality. Each bite offers a balance of tender meat and robust flavors, showcasing the meticulous preparation of every sandwich.
The attention to detail extends to the bread, ensuring that every element contributes to a harmonious taste experience. With a regal reputation for excellence, Pastrami Queen is a destination fit for food enthusiasts seeking the best of both worlds.
Address: 1125 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10075
Why They’re Best:
- Royalty of both pastrami and corned beef.
- Hand-sliced, melt-in-your-mouth goodness.
- Regal balance of flavors and textures.
- Known for their friendly and attentive service.
8. Court Street Grocers
Court Street Grocers takes the corned beef sandwich on a journey of international flavors. With an inventive approach, this establishment infuses creativity into every bite. Combining unexpected yet harmonious ingredients creates an adventure for the taste buds.
The corned beef is elevated by diverse accompaniments, resulting in a sandwich that’s as exciting as it is satisfying. Court Street Grocers captures the essence of culinary exploration and showcases the dynamic nature of New York City’s food scene.
Address: 540 LaGuardia Pl, New York, NY 10012
Why They’re Best:
- Fusion of international flavors.
- Creative and inventive corned beef sandwich.
- Showcasing the diversity of NYC’s food scene.
- Rotating menu that keeps things exciting.
9. Shelsky’s of Brooklyn
Shelsky’s of Brooklyn brings a seafood twist to the world of corned beef sandwiches. Their innovative combination of corned beef and herring results in an intriguing and memorable flavor profile. The rich, savory notes of the corned beef are complemented by the delicate saltiness of the herring, creating a harmonious symphony of tastes.
With its curated selection of delicacies, Shelsky’s of Brooklyn offers a one-of-a-kind experience that’s sure to delight adventurous eaters.
Address: 141 Court St., Brooklyn, NY 11201.
Why They’re Best:
- Seafood twist on tradition.
- Corned beef and herring combination.
- Unique and unforgettable flavors.
- Known for its curated selection of delicacies.
10. Frankel’s Delicatessen
Frankel’s Delicatessen, run by siblings, brings a unique blend of tradition and innovation to their corned beef sandwich. The sandwich seamlessly weaves classic flavors and modern twists, creating a harmonious and satisfying creation.
Each bite offers comfort and innovation, capturing the essence of both old and new. The cozy ambiance adds charm to the dining experience, making Frankel’s Delicatessen a beloved spot for locals seeking the perfect corned beef sandwich.
Address: 631 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Why They’re Best:
- Sibling-run, family-oriented spot.
- Traditional and modern blend in each sandwich.
- Comfort and innovation in every bite.
- Beloved by locals for its cozy ambiance.
FAQs:
Are these restaurants family-friendly?
Absolutely! Many of these establishments cater to families, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere for all ages.
What is the average price range for a corned beef sandwich?
Prices vary, but you can generally pay around $15 to $25 for a high-quality corned beef sandwich.
Do these restaurants offer takeout or delivery?
Yes, most of them provide takeout and delivery options, allowing you to enjoy these delectable sandwiches in your home.
Are reservations required?
Reservations might be necessary for certain peak hours or days, so it’s a good idea to check ahead of time, especially if you’re planning a visit during busy periods.
Can I customize my sandwich?
Absolutely! Many of these establishments offer customization options, allowing you to tailor your corned beef sandwich to your preferences.
Are vegetarian or vegan options available?
Yes, some restaurants on the list offer vegetarian or vegan versions of the classic corned beef sandwich, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
Conclusion:
Embarking on a journey through the 15 best-corned beef sandwiches in New York City is a compelling adventure for food enthusiasts. Each spot on this list offers a unique take on this beloved classic, from historic delis to innovative eateries.
Whether you’re a devoted fan of traditional flavors or eager to explore inventive twists, the corned beef sandwiches of New York City are sure to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds.
