Hey there, fellow pizza enthusiasts! If you’re a pizza lover like me and find yourself in the Big Apple, you’re in for a treat. New York City is a pizza paradise, and as a proud New Yorker, I’ve scoured the city to bring you the list of the top 13 pizza places.
These aren’t just your average pizzerias; these are the cream of the crust, the kings of the cheese, and the masters of the oven. So, get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey with me as we explore the best pizza Places in New York City.
Top 13 Pizza Places in New York City
1. Joe’s Pizza
Ah, Joe’s Pizza! Nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, Joe’s has been serving heavenly slices for over half a century. The thin, foldable slices here are a quintessential New York experience. My personal favorite? A classic Margherita. Simplicity at its best!
- Location: Greenwich Village
Related Post: Best Reuben in New York City
2. Di Fara Pizza
If you’re willing to take a little journey out to Brooklyn, Di Fara Pizza is worth every step. Dom DeMarco, the legendary pizzaiolo, handcrafts each pizza, ensuring perfection in every bite. Be prepared for a longer wait; trust me, it’s worth it.
- Location: Midwood, Brooklyn
3. Lombardi’s
Lombardi’s has a special place in New York’s pizza history as one of the oldest pizzerias in the United States. Their coal-oven pies are to die for, especially the white clam pizza. The cozy, historic atmosphere adds to the charm.
- Location: Little Italy
4. Grimaldi’s
If you wander in DUMBO (Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass), don’t miss Grimaldi’s. The coal-fired brick oven creates a crispy, slightly charred crust that pairs perfectly with fresh ingredients. Remember to snap a photo of the iconic Brooklyn Bridge while you’re here.
- Location: DUMBO, Brooklyn
5. Juliana’s Pizza
Right next door to Grimaldi’s, Juliana’s is another gem you must pay attention to. The rivalry between these two spots is legendary; you must taste them to pick your favorite. I love Juliana’s slightly more, but I’ll let you be the judge.
- Location: DUMBO, Brooklyn
See Also: Best Restaurants in Newburgh, New York
6. Patsy’s Pizzeria
Patsy’s is another slice of history, having been around since 1933. Their thin-crust pizzas with perfectly seasoned tomato sauce are irresistible. Pair your slice with a cannoli for a truly New York experience.
- Location: East Harlem
7. Prince Street Pizza
You can only talk about New York pizza if you mention pepperoni. Prince Street Pizza offers one of the best pepperoni slices in the city. The spicy, crispy pepperoni cups on their “Spicy Spring” slice are a game-changer.
- Location: Nolita
8. Artichoke Basille’s Pizza
Are you looking for something a bit different? Artichoke Basille’s is famous for its unconventional and indulgent slices, like the artichoke and spinach pizza. It’s rich, creamy, and pure pizza artistry.
- Location: Multiple locations
9. Roberta’s
Roberta’s is different from your typical pizza place. It’s a hipster haven in the heart of Brooklyn, known for its wood-fired, innovative pizzas. If you’re feeling adventurous, try their Bee Sting pizza, which combines honey and chili for an unforgettable kick.
- Location: Bushwick, Brooklyn
10. Lucali
Lucali is one place where you must make a reservation a week in advance. But once you taste their coal-oven pizza, you’ll understand why. The simplicity of the ingredients and the perfect dough make it worth the wait.
- Location: Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Read More: Best Restaurant For Diners in New York
11. Motorino
Motorino is all about the Neapolitan pizza experience. The blistered, chewy crust and the finest imported toppings make this place a must-visit. The Brussels sprouts and pancetta pizza are my personal favorites.
- Location: East Village
12. Emily
At Emily, you’ll find a unique take on pizza. Their creative combinations and the perfectly charred crust set them apart. If you’re a truffle fan, catch the Emily with truffle sottocenere, mozzarella, and pistachio.
- Location: Clinton Hill, Brooklyn
13. John’s of Bleecker Street
We round up our pizza tour with John’s of Bleecker Street. The classic, no-frills atmosphere and the coal-fired oven create pure, nostalgic pizzas. Their pies are generously topped with fresh ingredients and incredible flavors.
- Location: Greenwich Village
FAQs
Are these pizza places budget-friendly?
The affordability of these pizzerias varies, but you can find something for every budget. Places like Joe’s Pizza and Prince Street Pizza offer more budget-friendly options, while upscale spots like Lucali and Roberta’s might require more dough.
Do these places offer gluten-free options?
Some of the pizzerias on the list provide gluten-free crust options, but it’s always a good idea to check with the specific restaurant beforehand, as the availability can change.
Can I get a vegan pizza in New York City?
Absolutely! New York City is known for its diverse culinary scene, and many pizzerias offer vegan and vegetarian pizza options. Spots like Artichoke Basille’s and Roberta’s have some delightful vegan choices.
Conclusion
That’s a wrap, pizza lovers! These are the top 13 pizza places in New York City, each with unique charm and flavor. But remember, this list is just the tip of the pizza slice; New York City is filled with hidden pizza gems waiting to be discovered. So, grab a slice (or more) and savor the essence of the city that never sleeps.
